EN AR

Trump sours on Vance over Iran war criticism, NYT reports

SAFAA SUBHI

Key Points

  1. Trump has told aides Vance should have defended the Iran war decision, The New York Times reported.
  2. Vance blamed the war and ties with Israel for the Republican midterm defeat.
  3. The rift lands as Vance weighs whether to run for president in 2028.

The latest:

President Donald Trump has grown frustrated with Vice President JD Vance over his criticism of the war on Iran, The New York Times reported Wednesday, citing people familiar with his comments. Trump has complained to aides and allies over the past two weeks that Vance should have made clear the president made the right call in going to war.

Details:

  • The complaint: According to the Times, Trump’s irritation centers on how Vance framed the reasons for the Republican midterm defeat. People familiar with the president’s remarks said he argued his deputy was obliged to state publicly that the decision to strike Iran was correct, rather than treat it as a liability.
  • The Rubio shift: The Times reported that Trump has begun praising Secretary of State Marco Rubio in private, hinting he could be the strongest contender in the next presidential race. Unlike Vance, Rubio has repeatedly called the strike decision necessary for national security and has not questioned it.
  • The post: Earlier this month Trump said his vice president should have issued “another statement,” a reference to the unusual post Vance published on X after the heavy congressional loss. In it, Vance claimed the Iran war was the main driver of the Republican rout and pointed to the US relationship with Israel as a key factor pushing voters toward the Democrats, a conclusion he said followed from polling.
  • Trump’s response: Trump addressed the analysis shortly afterward, saying Vance was right about the politics but insisting the war was worth it. He has not publicly withdrawn that assessment, even as he privately faults his deputy for not defending the decision more forcefully.
  • The 2028 question: CNN reported over the weekend that Vance was seriously considering not running for president in 2028 after the midterm defeat. No final decision has been made, the network said, with Vance weighing his ambitions against the fracturing of the MAGA coalition and family demands in talks with about a dozen allies and advisers.
  • The military track: The commander of US Central Command, Admiral Brad Cooper, is visiting Israel, a trip described as highly consequential given the possibility of renewed fighting. Benjamin Netanyahu, serving as interim prime minister, was due to hold a security discussion on Iran the same day.
  • The Iranian claim: Tehran continues to direct threats at the United States and Israel, and claims the Republican midterm loss amounts in itself to a clear Iranian victory. Sources said Trump is under heavy pressure, with advisers divided over the best course against the Iranian government.
  • The flashpoint: The situation in the Strait of Hormuz remains tense, with the possibility of a renewed confrontation between Washington and Tehran, potentially involving Israeli participation. No timeline has been set for any next move.

Between the lines:

The reported turn toward Rubio is the sharper signal. Trump’s private praise for a secretary of state who never questioned the strike, set against his complaints about a vice president who tied it to an electoral collapse, suggests the 2028 succession is being judged first on loyalty to the Iran decision. Vance’s own deliberations, as reported by CNN, run in the same direction.

What’s next

Watch Netanyahu’s Iran security discussion and the outcome of Admiral Cooper’s visit to Israel, any further Trump comment on Rubio’s prospects, and whether Vance announces a decision on a 2028 run.

What to read next