Key Points
- The Senate voted down a measure to block further Trump strikes on Iran, 51-48.
- Three Republicans backed it; Democrat John Fetterman voted no in the chamber.
- First test of GOP support for the war since the party's midterm defeat.
The latest:
A resolution to bar President Donald Trump from ordering further strikes on Iran failed in the Senate on Thursday, 51-48, with three Republicans joining Democrats. It was the first measure of Republican support for the war since the party lost control of Congress in this month’s midterm elections. Senator John Fetterman of Pennsylvania was the lone Democrat to vote against.
Details:
- The tally: The resolution failed 51-48, with three Republicans crossing over to back it, according to The Washington Post. Fetterman broke with his party to oppose it. Senator Chris Murphy of Connecticut, recovering from a stroke he suffered last month, missed the vote.
- The opposition: Senator Tim Sheehy, Republican of Montana, spoke against the measure on the floor, arguing the United States could not ignore the threat posed by Iran. He told colleagues, “Iran is not a war of choice. It’s a war of necessity.”
- The Democratic case: Senator Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin said before the vote that time was of the essence, and urged colleagues to act on the message voters sent this month rather than wait for the next Congress to end the war.
- House history: The same resolution cleared the House in September with seven Republican votes. Five of those Republicans were on the ballot this month, and four lost reelection, indicating the vote offered little protection from voter anger over the war.
- Limited effect: Even had it passed, the resolution would not have forced Trump to end the war. It cannot be vetoed, but the White House ignored a similar measure Congress approved in June, leaving enforcement unresolved.
- The legal fight: The White House and Republicans contend the Supreme Court has held such resolutions unconstitutional, citing the 1983 ruling in Immigration and Naturalization Service v. Chadha, which barred Congress from restraining the president’s veto power in that manner.
- Democratic rebuttal: Democrats argue courts have never examined whether the Chadha precedent extends to war powers resolutions specifically. The 1973 War Powers Resolution requires the president to withdraw forces from unauthorized hostilities once Congress passes such a measure.
- Inside the GOP: Trump considered resuming military strikes after the midterms but has mostly held off, according to the report. Many Republicans, including Vice President JD Vance, have blamed the party’s midterm wipeout on the war’s unpopularity.
- Funding leverage: Democrats have pledged to end the war but are still debating strategy. Some Senate Democrats have called for refusing to pass a government funding bill next month if it includes money for the Iran campaign.
Background:
The 1973 War Powers Resolution lets Congress force a vote compelling withdrawal of U.S. forces from hostilities it never authorized. Democrats used that mechanism to bring Thursday’s measure to the floor, and used it again in June for a similar resolution the White House did not act on.
Between the lines:
The 51-48 margin shows Republican defections remain in single digits even after a midterm loss that Vance himself tied to the war. The House precedent cuts both ways: seven Republicans voted yes in September, and four of the five who faced voters lost anyway. That record gives wavering senators little electoral incentive to break ranks, and pushes Democrats toward the funding fight instead.
What’s next
The federal government is set to shut down Dec. 12 unless Congress approves more funding, making that bill the next venue for Democrats weighing whether to strip money for the Iran campaign.