EN AR

Jurf al-Sakhar: Is the Militia Retreating, or Is the State Reclaiming Its Authority?

Ahmed Kawa

The most revealing part of Kataib Hezbollah’s statement on Jurf al-Sakhar was not what its secretary-general, Abu Hussein al-Hamidawi, said, but what he carefully left unsaid.

He instructed his fighters to stand down from their state of alert and return to their normal duties. He spoke of resolving the dispute with the prime minister through established channels. Yet he made no explicit commitment to withdraw, surrender weapons, or relinquish the control the militia has exercised over the area for years.

And therein lies the paradox.

A confrontation that began as a test of authority between the Iraqi state and an armed faction now appears to be moving toward a political accommodation designed to avert bloodshed, without necessarily resolving the question at the heart of the dispute.

There is a profound difference between government forces entering Jurf al-Sakhar and Jurf al-Sakhar returning to government authority.

The first is a military deployment. The second is a transformation in the very nature of power.

Who will have the authority to arrest and search? Who will control the roads, checkpoints, and oil infrastructure? And whose orders will prevail when the interests of an armed faction collide with the decisions of the state?

These are not procedural details. They are the substance of sovereignty.

Iran’s involvement adds another, more consequential dimension.

When al-Hamidawi acknowledges the participation of Esmail Qaani, commander of Iran’s Quds Force, in efforts to resolve the crisis, it becomes difficult to regard the confrontation as an exclusively Iraqi affair.

There is nothing surprising about Tehran seeking to preserve the influence of its allies. States pursue their interests. That is the ordinary grammar of international politics.

But Baghdad faces a more fundamental question: Why should a dispute over the control of Iraqi territory require the mediation of an Iranian military commander when Iraq’s own constitutional institutions are supposed to exercise sovereign authority?

The government has announced the formation of a joint security command, scheduled to begin operating on Friday morning, bringing together the army, police, and Popular Mobilization Forces.

Yet changing the names of military formations or rearranging their positions does not, by itself, establish that authority has changed hands.

A militia need not occupy every checkpoint to retain influence over a territory. Power can survive behind official uniforms, administrative arrangements, and informal networks of command.

The distinction becomes even more important in light of government investigations into suspected oil smuggling, allegations that Kataib Hezbollah denies.

An agreement to prevent armed confrontation must not become an arrangement that quietly disposes of unresolved legal questions. Security negotiations cannot substitute for judicial accountability.

Nor should the people of Jurf al-Sakhar disappear from the discussion.

Many residents have been unable to return to their homes for years. Restoring state authority cannot be measured solely by military deployments. It must also mean reopening roads, restoring civilian life, and allowing displaced families to exercise their rights.

The mediation may succeed in preventing another confrontation between Iraqis. That would be a meaningful achievement, and one that should not be dismissed.

But preventing a war is not the same as restoring sovereignty.

Friday morning’s real test will not be how many soldiers enter Jurf al-Sakhar. It will be who possesses the authority to command them once they are there.

A state does not reclaim its territory merely by raising its flag above it.

It reclaims that territory when its laws and institutions become the final authority over everyone who lives or operates there, without exceptions, intermediaries, or permission from beyond its borders.

More from Ahmed Kawa

More analysis and perspectives by this author
No other articles by this author yet