EN AR

Christie’s Pulls Contested Frida Kahlo Painting Hours Before Auction

Tamara khadrah

Key Points

  1. Christie's withdrew a 1952 Frida Kahlo painting from its New York sale hours before bidding opened Tuesday.
  2. The work was publicly reported missing last year from Mexico City's Casa Azul house-museum.
  3. Diego Rivera left the collection in trust to Mexicans in 1955, barring removal from the property.

The latest:

A 1952 Frida Kahlo painting carrying a pre-sale estimate of $2.5 million to $3.5 million was pulled from Christie’s 20th-Century Evening Sale on Tuesday, hours before bidding was due to begin. The auction house said the decision was taken in collaboration with the seller to allow further research, and said it still expects to sell the work at a later date.

Details:

  • The work: The painting is titled “Congreso de los pueblos por la Paz (Congress of Peoples for Peace).” It depicts a dove perched in a fruit tree flanked by nuclear mushroom clouds, and Kahlo created it to mark a 1952 pacifist gathering held in Vienna, Austria.
  • The withdrawal: A Christie’s spokesperson said the lot was removed from the 20th-Century Evening Sale for further research, in collaboration with the seller, and that the house looks forward to selling the work at a later date. The spokesperson did not name the seller or give a new sale date.
  • The allegation: Hilda Trujillo, director of the Casa Azul from 2009 to 2020, alleged last year that several Kahlo artworks went missing in the decades before she took charge of the museum. She named this painting among them, according to The New York Times.
  • The trust: Diego Rivera, Kahlo’s husband, left thousands of items in trust to the Mexican people in 1955, a year after Kahlo’s death. The holdings included artworks, photographs, clothing, letters and pre-Hispanic artifacts, and the disputed painting was part of the Casa Azul collection.
  • The condition: Rivera stipulated that the collection should remain intact and never leave the Casa Azul property, the celebrated Mexico City house-museum where Kahlo once lived. That condition sits directly against the painting’s appearance in a commercial sale in New York.
  • The reporting trail: The painting had been publicly reported missing from the Casa Azul last year, before it surfaced in the Christie’s catalogue. The auction house has not said how it established the chain of ownership that brought the work to sale.
  • The money: The pre-sale estimate of $2.5 million to $3.5 million placed the painting among the notable lots of the evening sale. No bids were taken, since the withdrawal came before the session opened.
  • The outstanding questions: Christie’s has not disclosed what the further research covers, who is conducting it, or how long it will take. Neither Mexican cultural authorities nor the Casa Azul’s current management have been named as parties to the review.

Background:

The Casa Azul, Kahlo’s lifelong home in Mexico City, became a museum after Rivera placed the couple’s belongings in a national trust in 1955. Its collection of paintings, personal effects and artifacts is treated as Mexican patrimony rather than private property.

Between the lines:

The gap at the center of the case is between Rivera’s 1955 condition that the collection never leave the Casa Azul and the painting’s arrival at a New York evening sale with a seller attached. Christie’s framing of the pause as research, paired with its statement that it still expects to sell the work, signals the house treats the ownership question as unresolved rather than closed.

What’s next

Watch for Christie’s to disclose the outcome of its research and any rescheduled sale date, and for a response from Mexican cultural authorities or the Casa Azul on whether they will pursue a claim to the painting.

What to read next