The Latest
Jens Spahn, one of Germany’s most senior conservative politicians and a close ally of Chancellor Friedrich Merz, has resigned as parliamentary leader of the CDU/CSU following mounting criticism over his decision to become a father through surrogacy in the United States. The controversy centred not on Spahn becoming a parent, but on accusations that his private decision contradicted a policy he had publicly defended for years. After growing pressure from within his own party and the opposition, Spahn concluded that remaining in one of Germany’s most powerful political offices had become incompatible with his personal decision.
Details
- A key figure steps down: As parliamentary leader of the CDU/CSU bloc, Spahn was responsible for steering Chancellor Merz’s legislative agenda through parliament and maintaining support within Germany’s governing coalition. His resignation removes one of the chancellor’s closest political allies at a crucial time for the government.
- Why the backlash grew: Critics accused Spahn of applying different standards to his private life than those he supported politically. Germany bans surrogacy, and the CDU reaffirmed its opposition to changing the law at a party conference in February. Spahn had also rejected calls to relax the ban while serving as health minister and had previously written that, “as a gay man and a Christian”, he found the idea of a “rented womb” difficult to accept.
- Spahn’s explanation: Announcing his resignation, Spahn said becoming a father with his husband had made him realise that his personal happiness was “incompatible” with continuing in his political role. He also acknowledged that he had wrestled with the decision before choosing to pursue surrogacy abroad.
- Merz stands by party policy: Merz described Spahn’s resignation as “right and unavoidable”, saying credibility is the most valuable asset in politics. While praising Spahn’s contribution to returning the CDU to government, the chancellor said he saw no reason to change the party’s longstanding opposition to surrogacy.
- The legal position: Surrogacy remains illegal in Germany, although German citizens may legally raise children born through surrogacy abroad. The distinction has allowed prospective parents to seek surrogacy overseas while leaving Germany’s domestic ban unchanged.
What Else
- Successor to be chosen: The CDU/CSU parliamentary group is expected to begin the process of selecting a new leader to manage the coalition’s legislative agenda in parliament.
- Political fallout: Spahn’s resignation deprives Merz of one of his most experienced allies and comes as the CDU prepares for key regional elections later this year, increasing pressure on the governing coalition to move past the controversy.
- Credibility in focus: The episode has reignited debate over whether elected officials should be held to the same standards as the policies they publicly advocate, with critics arguing the controversy was ultimately about political credibility rather than surrogacy itself.
